Rosey and Dewey Butt
Before I get to the latest mini-debunking kit, I'd like to take a moment
to focus on that noblest of media: television.
Last night, on Larry King Live, famous and inaccurate psychic Sylvia
Browne appeared on a panel with two other psychics to debate two skeptics
(on of whom was a Rabbi). I'd always wanted to into a talk show and ask
a psychic to contact my dead brother. Since I never had a brother, I
always assumed that this would be a great source of amusement until
none-other-than James Randi, himself, explained to me that, as soon as
I revealed that I never had a brother, the psychic would inevitably
counter with some crazy cover story about how some malevolent spirit
had contacted them pretending to be my brother. Plan B was to
call and ask Sylvia why she wasn't able to predict that eating fifty
pounds of Ben & Jerry's would turn her into a reasonable facsimile of
a lowland gorilla.
Finally, I settled on Plan C which consisted of drinking several glasses
of wine while mocking the "people" who did call in: who were all
pro-psychic.
Speaking of television shows which are composed mostly of idiots, I highly
recommend that you check out no-more-than fifteen minutes of Moral Court.
The show is basically a variation on all of those other daytime courtroom
shows (Judge Judy, Judge, Joe Brown, The People's Court, Judge Hatchet,
Divorce Court, etc.) in which people facing complex moral dilemmas, such
as "Should I sell me baby to Satanists?" and "What color should I paint
my Meth lab?" have the concepts of Right and Wrong explained to them very,
very, slowly. Up next: Basic Hygiene Court.
OK, now that I've gotten that off my chest, let's debunk some shit!
-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.
One of my all-time favorite headlines from the Onion is Sacco, Vanzetti
Executed For Murder, Italian Descent. I found myself thinking about
that headline, recently, when I found myself debating the death penalty
with a pro-capitol punishment, Italian-American. When I asked him how,
consider what happened to Sacco and Venzetti, he, of all people, could be
in favor of the government putting citizens to death, his answer was
simply "Who?" Clearly, he hadn't been doing his homework.
I, on the other hand, have been doing mine. My opposition to capitol
punishment is, unlike many others, not based on any moral argument, but
on the facts that I've managed to glean during my brief sobriety which
took place in the early nineties. I should also mention that even if
Sylvia Browne were facing death-by-chocolate, I (along with Greenpeace
who never like to see a whale hunted down) would oppose her execution.
Death Penalty Mini-Debunking Kit
1. The Death Penalty does not deter crime. Murders are either
crimes of passion or they're premeditated. Agreed? I think we can also
agree that, except in crappy Sci-Fi films starring sofa-leaping
Scientologists, it's impossible to prevent crimes of passion. As for
premeditated crimes, well, the individuals who commit these crimes tend
to consider themselves to be too smart to get caught: otherwise they
wouldn't be out there pulling that drive-by shooting at two in the
afternoon in front of a local news crew, now would they?
2. The Death Penalty may actually lead to an increase in the murder
rate. Statistics seldom lie: the murder rate in non-death penalty
states has continually remained lower than in states which employ
execution; and, as number of people put to death has grown, the greater
this divide has become. In 1990, the murder rates between pro and non
death penalty states differed by 4%. By 2000, you stood a 35% higher
chance of getting killed in death penalty state than in a state without
the death penalty. In 2001 that number went up to 37% and dropped,
slightly, in 2002, to 36%. Of the twenty states with the highest murder
rates today, eighteen have the death penalty.
3. Most Western Democracies have abolished capitol punishment.
By continuing to hang on to this barbaric practice, the United States
finds itself in the company of such truly enlightened countries as China,
Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Yemen, Kuwait, Vietnam, Egypt, and Belarus
(where, I have it on good authority, all of the women look like Sylvia
Browne).
4. Blacks get to "ride the lighting" more than Whites. While Trevor
Boswell-Pennington IV is ten times more likely to get his WASPish skull
smashed in by Rakim Washington than vice-versa, and while fifty-seven
percent of the people on Death Row are White, Blacks are five times more
likely to be sentenced to death than Whites. Oh, and since 1977, 85% of
the murderers executed in Utah were convicted of killing a white person,
as opposed to only 11% who were executed for killing black persons.
5. Poor people get to "ride the lighting" more than rich people.
It shouldn't come as a surprise to no one (well, maybe Bill O'Reilly) that,
in the words of Justice William O. Douglas, "One searches our chronicles
in vain for the execution of any member of the affluent strata in this
society." 90 % of the people on death row couldn't afford to hire a
lawyer. Good luck with Mr. Court-Appointed Attorney, Carlos; you're gonna
need it.
6. Women rarely, if ever, get to ride "ride the lighting". Even
though women commit about 15% of the murders in America, they comprise
only 1% of the death row population. Since 1930, the USA (USA! USA!) has
only executed 33 women (none of whom were Sylvia Browne)
7. We have now sunk to the point where we're executing the mentally
retarded. Even though numerous studies have shown that and the
mentally impaired (as well as minors) are more vulnerable to suggestion
than any other segment of the population and, therefore, more likely to
make false confessions, the United States continues to sentence them to
death. Ricky Ray Rector, who was convicted of the 1979 rape and murder
of Pamela Moseley Carpenter, had an IQ of approximately 60: which means
that his reasoning capabilities were on par with that of a seven-year-old.
Ricky asked if he could save the dessert from his last meal so that he
could have it as a snack later…after his execution.
8. The Death Penalty is irreversible. Simply put: if you're
sentenced to life for a murder, and you're later found to be innocent,
you can be released. You can't undo an execution. While the likelihood
of a mistake being made is incredibly low (roughly 0.33 of 1%), mistakes
do happen. We know of twenty-five people who were wrongfully executed
in America during the twentieth century.
-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.
OK, since I like to switch back-and-forth, debunking both the Left and
the Right, the next time we play this game, it'll be with Afrocentrism.
sententia -ae - feeling, thought, opinion
vote, sentence
Rodney on 12.29.05 @ 09:31 PM EST [link] [No Comments]









